
Cortada speaks at William & Mary’s Muscarelle Museum
Tuesday, October 28, 2025
Muscarelle Museum of Art
611 Jamestown Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185
At the Muscarelle Museum of Art on the campus of William & Mary—founded in 1693 and among the nation’s oldest universities—Miami-based artist Xavier Cortada delivered an artist talk that advanced a careful argument that art can help communities face reality together. Organized under William & Mary’s Year of the Environment and presented within the museum’s Muscarelle Explorations series, Cortada’s lecture, “Reclaiming Truth: Art as a Force for Environmental Justice and Collective Action,” braided philosophy, place-based storytelling, and participatory case studies into a civic proposition: truth isn’t merely gathered as data; it’s practiced in public.
Why truth, and why here?
Cortada opened by situating “truth” in the present tense: hours before his talk, a Category 5 hurricane made landfall in Jamaica—a visceral reminder that warming seas are not abstractions. He argued that even as lived reality intensifies, climate science is diluted, delayed, or displaced in public discourse. The point was not partisan, but ethical: when evidence is minimized precisely as urgency grows, society loses the very knowledge it needs to act.
Cortada approached “truth” less as a stack of facts and more as a living discipline that can be nurtured or neglected. In a culture thick with spectacle and distraction, he suggested, truth is often less refuted than drowned out. Museums and universities, he noted with appreciation, can serve as convening grounds where that signal is amplified rather than lost—spaces where art is engaged not only as object, but as relationship, process, and civic tool.
Framed this way, the talk situated the Muscarelle as a place to test ideas openly and generously: a museum that makes room for difficult questions, shared inquiry, and practical experiments that reach beyond the gallery.
At the level of government, Cortada argued, truth is obscured when public knowledge is narrowed—whether by the rollback of environmental safeguards, the softening of scientific language, or the sidelining of research that should inform policy. When institutions that exist to measure and protect are constrained from doing so, the public loses its compass; the shared facts required for democratic decision-making are diluted before they can guide action.
At the level of business, truth is blurred when marketing reframes responsibility and risk—when green claims outpace practice, when costs are externalized to communities and ecosystems, and when narratives shift blame away from systemic drivers. In that landscape, the public is offered polished narratives that distract from material realities on the ground.
At the personal level, truth is muffled by habit and comfort: the rationalizations that everything is fine, the impulse to look away, the belief that individual choices cannot add up to collective change. Cortada emphasized that this isn’t about shame; it’s about courage—choosing to see what is there, even when it is inconvenient, and choosing to act with others in public.
Of these, Cortada named the most dangerous untruth as the one we tell ourselves: that we do not have agency. That we cannot move policy, markets, or culture. That our role is to spectate. He countered that truth is not only what we verify; it is also what we are willing to enact. Agency, he argued, is rekindled by practice—small, public, repeated acts that stitch responsibility back to place.
Three participatory works as methods—not just artworks
To demonstrate how truth can be cultivated in public, Cortada presented three projects that enlist people as co-creators and narrators of place:
Native Flags — A simple ritual: plant a native tree and mark the commitment with a small flag. The gesture is intimate and public at once, transforming private stewardship into a visible vow. Participants learn species, soil, and neighborhood ecology while making a promise legible to others. In Native Flags, the conspicuous green flag beside a newly planted native tree does more than decorate a yard; it reveals a decision a passerby would otherwise miss. The flag makes the invisible visible: a commitment to rebuild urban canopy for shade, cooling, pollinators, stormwater uptake, and other ecosystem services. The object becomes a prompt for conversation, a neighborhood aperture onto shared ecological work.
Reclamation Project — A citywide invitation to nurture mangrove propagules and return them to coastal habitats, reframing restoration as a shared civic rite. The project’s pedagogy—caring, tracking, returning—becomes a community curriculum about belonging (human and nonhuman), shorelines, and resilience. In Reclamation Project, placing mangrove propagules where mangroves once thrived exposes an absence that the built environment has normalized. The installation surfaces a prior ecology, a memory of coastlines that buffered storm surge, fostered nurseries for marine life, and knit human settlements to tidal rhythms. By reinstalling what was removed, the work performs a quiet indictment and a practical invitation: restoration as public pedagogy.
The Underwater — Elevation markers and yard signs (“I live at 7 feet”) that spatialize risk block by block. By asking residents to find and display their elevation, the work translates sea-level projections into neighborhood knowledge. What begins as a number becomes a conversation about vulnerability, equity, infrastructure, and preparedness. In The Underwater, Cortada “maps topography” at the human scale—elevations rendered as yard signs and street markers that localize sea-level rise. “I live at 7 feet” is not metaphor; it is a personal datum made public. Elevation numbers turn neighborhoods into legible risk fields, converting abstraction into proximity. As residents post their signs, they are not consuming a message; they are speaking a truth about where they stand—literally—and what that implies for preparedness and policy.
Across these examples, participation is the medium—art not as ornament but as method—reorganizing attention and returning factual truth to lived experience. By revealing what is already there—a planted tree, a missing forest, the number beneath our feet—participatory artworks move audiences from recognition to responsibility. The truth is not only told; it is co-produced by those who choose to see and act together.
Place matters: Southeast Virginia’s stakes—and an activation on site
Cortada connected the projects to local conditions. Southeast Virginia is among the nation’s most vulnerable coastal regions, living with recurrent flooding, subsidence, and accelerating sea-level rise. In that context, The Underwater gained immediate relevance. After the lecture, attendees looked up their home elevations and carried the conversation outward by taking home dozens of yard signs—an activation that moves from auditorium to sidewalk, from talk to visible public use beyond the museum.
That activation read as a public act of truth-telling. By carrying elevation home, participants did not simply endorse a message; they localized it. A sign on a lawn is not a slogan—it is a disclosure, a boundary line between denial and accountability, an invitation for neighbors to ask and learn. In that way, the museum became a staging ground for a truth that would circulate in the neighborhoods where it matters.
What “reclaiming truth” looks like in practice
The through-line in Cortada’s case studies is straightforward: make the invisible visible, invite people into authorship, and build forms that can be adopted by schools, neighborhoods, and agencies. Native Flags turns care into a visible promise. Reclamation Project turns a city into a nursery and a shoreline into a classroom. The Underwater turns a number into a neighborhood reckoning.
Rather than treating art as a discrete object, Cortada’s practice treats it as social infrastructure—frameworks that hold learning, memory, and participation over time. In that frame, museums become staging grounds for civic prototypes: places where an idea can be introduced, tested with a public, and carried into the world by the people who experienced it.
Cortada framed this as the work of building a culture of truth. Policies and markets matter, he noted, but so do the rituals that shape what communities see and say together. When a tree is planted with intention, when a mangrove is returned with care, when a yard sign names elevation in plain view, the truth is not only stated—it is shared, held, and rehearsed. That practice, repeated at scale, is how communities recover their bearings and their agency.
A museum as a gathering place for shared work
Throughout, Cortada spoke with gratitude for the Muscarelle’s role: a museum willing to convene an audience around hard questions and practical tools, and to do so within a university declaring a Year of the Environment. The lecture read as a collaborative gesture—artist, museum, and community in the same room, aligning attention on what is at stake and what can be tried together.
Takeaway
In a culture saturated with spectacle, distraction, and argument, truth is often less refuted than drowned out. Cortada’s proposition is that art can counter that drift by organizing attention and action in public: participatory forms that help communities see, feel, and do. At William & Mary’s Muscarelle, that proposition landed as both an artist’s talk and a local experiment—one that followed people out the door and into their neighborhoods as visible public practice.